Luboš Motl on Gillard's carbon nonsense

Climate sense

The highly esteemed blogger Luboš Motl (The Reference Frame) has contributed to the Aussie carbon tax debate:

To summarize, my quantitative analysis is meant to show that AUD 23 per ton makes no real difference to the consumption of fossil fuels – and surely not for the climate – and it’s just a step for the carbon fascists to test how much they can afford to harass the society (and they want to terrorize it much more in the future). They will surely steal millions out of this scheme and some of these parasites will be able to make a living but I want to assure the Australian readers that as long as the price is just AUD 23 per ton, it will not kill the Australian economy. It will just make all sources of energy 5-10 percent more expensive and steal a few hundred of corresponding dollars from your annual income. Nothing will detectably change about the CO2 emissions.

If the carbon tax were supposed to make a difference, it would have to be $700-$1,400 per ton. In that case, most of the world population would go extinct because just for breathing, an average human would have to pay $300-$700 per year of a carbon tax. For billions of people, such an annual fee would automatically mean that they will starve to death. If someone wants to remove most of the human contribution to the warming in the 21st century – something like 0.5 °C – by a carbon tax, he will surely have to introduce a carbon tax that will kill billions of people.

Is that really a good decision? Or is it legitimate to charge the people who promote carbon regulation with their planned crimes against humanity? I am sure that no country will be able to introduce a $300-per-ton CO2 tax. The likes of Gillard who would try to do so would be rightfully assassinated as soon as they would propose a $100-per-ton or so – that’s about the critical point.

Read it all.

Comments

  1. Keep in mind it’s not just a carbon tax that we will be paying. If the price of energy goes up, the price of everything goes up.

  2. Baldrick says:

    Speaking of $23 per tonne, Bob Brown said:
    ‘‘We take the Garnaut prescription for a carbon tax upon the polluters – not on the people – of $23 per tonne, indexed at the CPI, plus 4 per cent per annum,’’
    You think he said this in July 2011? Nope. How about February 2011? Nope.
    Try 25 July 2010.
    Tell me again who is running our Government?

    Source: http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/federal-election/greens-will-force-through-carbon-price-brown-20100725-10q99.html

  3. Lubos, please email me your addres, I will send you a coppy of my book.

Trackbacks

  1. […] http://www.australianclimatemadness.com/2011/07/lubos-motl-on-gillards-carbon-nonsense/ To summarize, my quantitative analysis is meant to show that AUD 23 per ton makes no real difference to the consumption of fossil fuels – and surely not for the climate – and it’s just a step for the carbon fascists to test how much they can afford to harass the society (and they want to terrorize it much more in the future). They will surely steal millions out of this scheme and some of these parasites will be able to make a living but I want to assure the Australian readers that as long as the price is just AUD 23 per ton, it will not kill the Australian economy. It will just make all sources of energy 5-10 percent more expensive and steal a few hundred of corresponding dollars from your annual income. Nothing will detectably change about the CO2 emissions. […]